Every Jean-Pierre Melville Film Ranked

Jean-Pierre Melville made thirteen features between 1949 and 1972, most of them about men in hats doing their jobs well and dying for it. He worked outside the French industry before the New Wave made that fashionable, owned his own studio, and was the older filmmaker the Cahiers critics held up as proof that it…

Jean-Pierre Melville made thirteen features between 1949 and 1972, most of them about men in hats doing their jobs well and dying for it. He worked outside the French industry before the New Wave made that fashionable, owned his own studio, and was the older filmmaker the Cahiers critics held up as proof that it could be done. Godard even put him in Breathless. His later crime films are among the coolest things French cinema ever produced, and the most imitated.

This list covers what I’ve seen: 9 of the 13 features, plus his first short. Four are missing: Les Enfants terribles, Two Men in Manhattan, L’Aîné des Ferchaux and, most conspicuously, Le Deuxième Souffle. They’ll go in when I’ve seen them. For more on the man, see my Jean-Pierre Melville profile.

Every Jean-Pierre Melville Film Ranked

10. 24 heures de la vie d’un clown (24 Hours in the Life of a Clown, 1946)

With Beby, Maïss · 18 min

A surprising first film. An eighteen-minute portrait of Beby, an ageing circus clown Melville had loved since childhood, following him and his partner from one night’s show to the next: watching the street from a café for gags, eating spaghetti at home, then working the material into the act. It’s shot on stock that had expired years earlier, and it’s actually very well shot: quick on its feet and proto-New Wave in its manner, a decade early. Most oddly for Melville, it’s funny. It isn’t a comedy, exactly, but it has none of the austerity his style would tend towards. Melville disliked it and tried to bury it. It’s interesting enough for what it is.

9. Le Silence de la mer (1949)

Starring Howard Vernon, Nicole Stéphane, Jean-Marie Robain · 86 min

Technically, Le Silence de la mer is superb. For a first feature, made without the rights to Vercors’s clandestine Resistance novella and outside the industry altogether, it’s shot like the work of a master, and it shows all the technical tricks he’d go on to perfect. Conceptually, it’s strikingly modern. A cultured German officer billeted on an old man and his niece in occupied France talks to them every evening, and they resist him by never saying a word back. He’s the only character who speaks on screen. The problem is everything around that silence. The uncle narrates throughout, an incessant voice-over that tells us what the silence is meant to mean, and between the officer’s monologues and the narration the film almost becomes unbearable. It grates, it clashes, it frustrates. The idea is the silence, and the film rarely lets you hear it.

Alain Delon and Catherine Deneuve in Un Flic (1972)

8. Un flic (1972)

Starring Alain Delon, Catherine Deneuve, Richard Crenna · 98 min

I found this film disappointing. It has everything a great Melville needs: Delon in a trench coat, a bank robbery in a rain-lashed, deserted seaside town, Deneuve. It is typically Melvillean in many ways, yet it just isn’t gripping. Some set pieces work, the opening robbery especially, but by and large the film never feels as though it fully gets started. Its centrepiece, a near-wordless twenty-minute heist in which a man is lowered from a helicopter onto a moving train, is let down by model work that Delon himself complained looked fake. It’s a shame it caps his career, but you can’t blame him for that; it’s not like he knew it’d be his last.

7. Quand tu liras cette lettre (When You Read This Letter, 1953)

Starring Juliette Gréco, Philippe Lemaire · 104 min

Here is Melville still coming to terms with being Melville. It’s the only film he directed without writing or co-writing it. It was a commercial job, taken largely to pay for his studio, and it shows. It’s got the classic Melville style and fatalism, but the plot is overstuffed. It’s full of twists and turns that are really stops and starts. It’s never quite certain what it is. It isn’t a bad film. It’s a perfectly serviceable noir-ish melodrama with nothing outstanding about it, and you can see the director looking for a way out of it.

Bob le flambeur still

6. Bob le flambeur (1956)

Starring Roger Duchesne, Isabelle Corey · 102 min

It’s an odd thing. Bob le flambeur is often cited as a landmark, but to me it feels like Melville is still figuring himself out. There are traces of his brilliance, and there’s a great deal of New Wave anticipation: street shooting, handheld camera, natural light, even a jump cut. Godard nods to it twice in Breathless. It’s also like Paul Thomas Anderson’s Hard Eight, though the resemblance is hard to describe. Duchesne’s Bob, an ageing gambler with one last job in him (the Deauville casino on Grand Prix night), is great throughout. The heist itself never happens, because Bob can’t stop winning at the tables. Melville called it a comedy of manners. It isn’t an energetic film; it’s far too subtle for that. Technically, the film is great; most things work, it just never fully pulls together.

5. Léon Morin, prêtre (Léon Morin, Priest, 1961)

Starring Jean-Paul Belmondo, Emmanuelle Riva · 128 min

The performances here are incredible, so subtle and nuanced. In an Alpine town under occupation, a widowed communist atheist (Riva) goes to confession to provoke a young priest (Belmondo, fresh from Breathless and in a cassock). What follows is a long theological sparring match in which her conversion and her desire for him become impossible to separate. Neither actor ever says what the film is really about, and both let you see it anyway. It’s thought-provoking, understated and brilliant. That it isn’t higher is no insult. I just prefer the films above it, and they’re more Melville.

Yves Montand in Le Cercle Rouge

4. Le Cercle rouge (1970)

Starring Alain Delon, Bourvil, Gian Maria Volonté, Yves Montand · 140 min

Best known for its near-silent heist, almost half an hour long, on a jeweller’s in the Place Vendôme. Here Melville is more ambitious than he had ever been: three thieves, a cop, a fake Buddhist epigraph about men destined to meet in the red circle, and a running time of well over two hours. Yet the technical side feels a little weaker. Decaë shoots it in a deliberately drained, almost monochrome palette, and next to Le Samouraï it seems less sharp to me. There are some of the greatest long sequences ever shot, but around them are a lot of slightly dull scenes. The acting is great, with Montand’s alcoholic ex-cop marksman the best thing in it, the tone sits perfectly, and it oozes style. It was also by far the biggest hit of his career.

3. Le Doulos (1962)

Starring Jean-Paul Belmondo, Serge Reggiani · 108 min

A really stunning film. Silien (Belmondo) might be an informer, the “doulos” of the title, which is underworld slang for both a hat and a grass, and the film keeps you guessing right to its final shoot-out. The tracking shots and long takes are superb: one interrogation runs for nearly ten minutes in a single shot. Everyone in it delivers, and Belmondo is great. A lot of it has been pilfered over the years; think Tarantino and Reservoir Dogs. But it’s still so much more than its imitations. It’s the first true Melville-Melville film, the first time it all comes together: the slick technique, the understated men, men in action, and a pulsing tempo.

2. L’Armée des ombres (Army of Shadows, 1969)

Starring Lino Ventura, Simone Signoret, Paul Meurisse · 145 min

All in all, one of the greatest films ever made. What more is there to say? Melville had been in the Resistance himself, and his film of it is bleak and cold, and the cinematography matches it perfectly: grey skies, dim rooms, night after night. It isn’t a bombastic war film. Its set pieces include a traitor strangled with a tea towel in a borrowed house, because the neighbours might hear a gun, and a prisoner running for his life down a firing range, and neither has a note of music. It’s cold to the touch, quiet and probably off-putting to many. But it’s hard to say I feel put off by it. It’s brilliant.

Le Samourai (1967), Alain Delon

1. Le Samouraï (1967)

Starring Alain Delon, François Périer, Nathalie Delon · 105 min

An obvious top pick, but still the right one. The film is truly beautiful in every department: the production design, Decaë’s steel-grey cinematography, the pacing and the performances. Delon is flawless as Jef Costello, a hitman whose every gesture, down to trying keys one by one to steal a car, oozes cool, enigmatic perfection. It’s littered with tiny moments that stay with you for ages after watching it. It’s captivating from the first frame to the last, and it’s the coolest film about loneliness ever made.

One response

Leave a Reply